Who Is Red John In The Mentalist? Identity Revealed and Fans' Reactions
Discover how Red John's identity was revealed in *The Mentalist* and the mixed reactions from fans and cast alike.
War Season 1 Episode 8 ends with Carla and Morgan reaching their own settlement before the judge rules, including Zephyr shares, monthly payments and shared custody.

Before the court issues its ruling in HBO's War Season 1 finale, Morgan pulls Carla aside and proposes that they settle the divorce themselves. They agree that Carla will receive half of Morgan's shares in Zephyr, monthly payments, and shared custody of their son Gabe. Their lawyers are surprised by the agreement, but both legal teams later present it to the press as a favorable result for their own client.
That negotiated ending comes after an earlier attempt to settle falls apart. At the start of the finale, Morgan's lawyers from Cathcarts arrive at Taylor & Byrne ready to sign a settlement agreement. Before anything is signed, news breaks that Morgan's affair with Flora has become public. The two legal teams blame each other for the leak, and the planned signing collapses. The divorce case then continues into the courtroom before Carla and Morgan eventually decide to settle on their own terms.
Johnny finds a torn-up love letter Morgan wrote to Carla while searching St. John's office. He later shows the letter to Flora and tells her he thinks Morgan's lawyers may never have shown it to her. Flora eventually agrees to testify, and St. John's team decides to put her on the stand even though they recognize that doing so could create problems for their own case.
On the stand, Flora explains that Carla had joked about using her to test Morgan's loyalty. Flora says she chose to take part and was attracted to Morgan. She also acknowledges that Johnny arranged payment for her mother's conservatory in exchange for an NDA. When that payment is raised against her, Flora points out that Johnny had been working for Cathcarts.
Flora then produces Morgan's letter to Carla and reads it in court. The letter says Morgan wants Carla to receive a fair share of what they built together and of what comes next. Carla and Morgan exchange a warm look after the letter is read, and the judge says he expects to have a decision soon. Before that decision arrives, Morgan and Carla create their own settlement.
Carla's demand for Zephyr shares is established before Flora takes the stand. Carla tells her lawyers that she now wants half of Morgan's shares rather than cash because she believes they built the company together. During her testimony, she explains that she helped turn the original idea into a concept and brought celebrity contacts onto the platform early. She also acknowledges that Morgan later took Zephyr to another level.
Prue challenges Carla on cross-examination by questioning her about Zephyr's senior executives and revenue data. The questioning shows that Carla is not involved in the company's day-to-day operation. Carla says she never claimed to run the business day to day and maintains that her early contribution helped get the platform started.
Morgan asks why the lawyers cannot simply explain what happened with Flora and the loyalty test, but his attorneys warn that revealing the full story would make both sides look bad. After Flora's testimony and the reading of Morgan's letter, Morgan pulls Carla aside before the judge can rule. They choose a negotiated agreement instead of waiting for the court's decision.
The final agreement gives Carla half of Morgan's Zephyr shares, monthly payments, and shared custody of Gabe. Those are the terms the episode identifies when Carla and Morgan settle the case. The judge therefore does not deliver the decision that he had said was coming, because Carla and Morgan reach an agreement first.
Both legal teams then speak to the press about the settlement. Although the lawyers were initially surprised by the deal, each side presents it publicly as a victory for its client. The episode closes the central divorce case with the terms Carla and Morgan negotiated themselves rather than with a courtroom ruling in favor of one side.
Flora leaves the courthouse after her testimony. Carla thanks her and offers her a quieter way out, but Flora chooses the front entrance and walks out in view of the waiting photographers.
Johnny's ending unfolds across two separate scenes. He first returns to his apartment and discovers that Bella has already gone, so he leaves a letter for her. Later, Johnny goes to the Taylor & Byrne office and apologizes to Serena. He tells her he wants a chance to be a lawyer and a good person at Taylor & Byrne rather than Cathcarts. Serena responds that she no longer knows whether she can believe him.
Serena and Nick have their own conflict earlier in the episode after Flora is called to testify. During their argument, Nick reveals that Beatrice had voted against Serena becoming a partner at Cathcarts. In the final office sequence, Nick is trying to repair things with Serena when she goes into labor. Johnny fetches Nick, and Nick takes Serena toward the elevator while reassuring her about the family they are about to have.
After the courtroom conflict is settled, the finale returns to Carla and Morgan in France. They walk together on the beach and tell each other that they will always love one another. Morgan has a plane to catch, but he stays long enough to have hot chocolate with Carla and Gabe before leaving.
By that point, the legal result is already fixed by their agreement: Carla receives half of Morgan's Zephyr shares, monthly payments, and shared custody of Gabe. The judge does not choose a winner because the two sides settle before he gives his decision. Their lawyers are able to present the agreement publicly as a success for both clients.
The finale also gives closing beats to the other people drawn into the case. Flora leaves through the courthouse's front entrance, Johnny asks Serena for another chance at Taylor & Byrne, and Serena goes into labor with Nick beside her. Carla and Morgan's beach scene then serves as the episode's last major moment after the divorce settlement has been completed.
Ending explanation
EpisodeBreakdown may use automated tools to assist research, drafting, and formatting. Published pages are governed by our editorial and corrections policies, and source links are shown when they are available in the article record.
Discovery source: TVLine. The source identifies where the topic was discovered; EpisodeBreakdown is responsible for the commentary published on this page.
Reader response
Reactions and poll results are based on real reader responses. No account is required.